|
House
Budget Committee Chairman Paul Ryan (R-WI) introduced a sweeping proposal this
week to reform how federal and state governments address the issue of poverty
in America. His plan, "Expanding Opportunity in America," looks into
a number of ways to create new programs and bolster some existing federal
programs while eliminating others that just don't work. Ryan is becoming the
go-to Republican on poverty policy, which is key for a party that needs a more
welcoming message on the subject -- to borrow his upcoming book title,
"The Way Forward."
The
primary element of Ryan's plan calls for the creation of Opportunity Grants
that would change how the government conducts fighting poverty. This brings
together 11 existing streams of federal aid -- from food stamps to housing
assistance -- into block grants that would allow states to tailor aid packages
to the poor based on individual need. States would assign a caseworker to each
person applying for aid, and together the caseworker and the individual would
create a plan based on short- and long-term goals. These goals would form the
basis of a contract in which the states would continue to supply aid so long as
the person continued to live up to their end of the agreement -- whether it be
finding or maintaining a job, pursuing an education or remaining drug-free.
Ryan proposes
changes to the Earned Income Tax Credit. The EITC is one of the few proven ways
the government has to reduce poverty and encourage work, and he wants to
simplify the application process. In addition, he wants to make all childless
adults over 21 eligible to apply. He suggests adding the EITC to each paycheck
throughout the year, rather than distributing it as a one-time payment in each
year's tax refund.
There are
a number of fixes to education aid in the proposal, including converting Head Start
funding into a block grant to allow states to experiment with different models
for early education. A big part of the primary and secondary education
component is the consolidation of multiple federal programs into flexible block
grants to the states, which allows for more tailored solutions at the community
level. The proposal also reforms the accreditation process to allow more
institutions and specific courses to gain accreditation, thereby increasing the
education options for students seeking federal aid.
Ryan
addresses the problem of an exploding prison population and the negative effect
incarceration has on upward mobility. He proposes allowing federal judges more
flexibility in sentencing non-violent felons who would otherwise be subject to
mandatory minimums, and he wants to tailor prison education and rehabilitation
programs to those inmates most at risk for recidivism.
Ryan's
plan, which you can read in detail here, is a thoughtful consideration how to
address what
is wrong with federal aid to the poor. As Ryan notes, "Fifteen
percent of Americans live in poverty today -- over 46 million people." In
that, he sees opportunity: "There's a vast amount of untapped potential in
our country." Federal anti-poverty programs have done little to actually
reduce poverty ever since Lyndon Johnson began the so-called War on
Poverty 50 years ago. Ryan's plan calls for making aid more
effective and more accountable, two goals with which Washington is not
familiar.
To be
sure, Democrats are already trying to shoot holes in Ryan's plan. Rep. Chris
Van Hollen (D-MD), ranking Democrat on the House Budget Committee, says Ryan
loves block grants because they are easier to cut. Van Hollen and other House
Democrats also note Ryan has proposed cutting numerous federal programs and therefore
cannot be taken seriously. Only a statist would consider cost cutting a
negative trait.
The fact
is, many of Ryan's proposals, like prison education and improved education
funding, have already seen the light of day as individual legislative proposals
that have drawn bipartisan support. Democrats don't like his plan because it
would mean lifting people out of poverty and freeing them from their poverty
plantations. Ryan is also a possible 2016 presidential candidate,
which makes him a prime target.
Beyond
all the policy nitty gritty, the key takeaway from Ryan's effort is that the
GOP needs to do a better job of addressing poverty. Blue collar Americans need
to hear that Liberty can work for them. As American Enterprise Institute fellow
James Pethokoukis puts it, Ryan "sees
low-income Americans as underutilized assets who need to be reintegrated into
the work economy so they and America can reach full potential." This is
done, as Benjamin Franklin once said, "not [by] making them easy in
poverty, but leading or driving them out of it."
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.